The allure of short-term rentals (STRs) has captivated many real estate investors, promising attractive returns and flexible income streams. However, as we look ahead to 2025 and beyond, it's crucial for prospective investors to approach this market with realistic expectations. The landscape is evolving, presenting both opportunities and challenges. This article will provide insights to help you make informed decisions when considering STR investments in Oregon.

The Evolving Landscape: A Trend Towards Moderation

For several years, the short-term rental market experienced a boom, fueled by platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo, and a surge in travel demand. However, recent data suggests a shift, indicating a trending down in key performance indicators for many STR markets.

Occupancy Rates and Nightly Rates:

While specific data varies by location within Oregon, a general trend shows that the inflated occupancy rates and nightly rates seen during the pandemic and immediate post-pandemic travel surge are normalizing. We are seeing:

• Decreasing Occupancy: As more STRs enter the market and traditional hotels regain their footing, the overall occupancy rates for short-term rentals are experiencing a moderate decline. This means your property might sit vacant for more nights than it would have a year or two ago and using historical occupancy figures for underwriting may not be conservative enough.
• Stabilizing/Decreasing Nightly Rates: The intense competition and increased supply are also putting downward pressure on average nightly rates. While prime locations and unique properties may still command premium pricing, the days of consistently high rates across the board are becoming less common.
• 
  

Battling High Valuations, Interest Rates and Compounding the challenge are the current economic conditions:

• High Residential Valuations: Property values across Oregon remain elevated, making the initial acquisition cost for potential STRs significant. This high barrier to entry can make it harder to achieve attractive cash-on-cash returns, especially when factoring in other costs. Properties with existing STR permits that are transferrable are demanding a premium, regardless of investment performance.
• Elevated Interest Rates: The current interest rate environment directly impacts borrowing costs. Higher interest rates translate to larger monthly mortgage payments, further squeezing potential profits and extending the time it takes to recoup your initial investment.
• 
  

These factors combine to create a more challenging environment than what many investors experienced in the recent past. It's no longer a "set it and forget it" market; careful planning, diligent management, and a deep understanding of market nuances are paramount.

Strategic Recommendations for Oregon STR Investors

Despite the shifting landscape, short-term rentals can still be a viable investment in Oregon for those who approach it strategically. Here are our key recommendations:

1. Moderate Leverage is Key

In a market with increasing costs and potentially softer returns, relying heavily on debt can amplify risk. We strongly advise investors to consider moderate leverage. This means aiming for a higher down payment than might have been common in a more aggressive market.

• Reduced Monthly Payments: A larger down payment directly translates to smaller monthly mortgage obligations, providing more breathing room in your cash flow, especially during periods of lower occupancy or reduced nightly rates.
• Increased Equity Buffer: Higher equity provides a stronger financial cushion against market fluctuations and unexpected expenses. If the market experiences a downturn, you have more equity to absorb potential losses before facing significant financial strain.
• Greater Financial Stability: Moderate leverage enhances your overall financial stability, making your investment less susceptible to interest rate hikes or shifts in rental income. It allows you to weather economic storms more comfortably.
• 
  

2. Understanding Area Restrictions: Especially True in Oregon

Oregon has a diverse regulatory landscape for short-term rentals, and understanding local area restrictions is absolutely critical before you even consider purchasing a property. Unlike some states with broad, uniform STR laws, Oregon's regulations are often determined at the county and city level, leading to significant variations.

• Varying Definitions and Permitting: What constitutes a "short-term rental" can differ, as can the requirements for permits and licenses. Some cities may require you to be a primary resident to operate an STR, while others allow non-owner-occupied units. For example, Portland has strict regulations, often requiring the STR to be in your primary residence, while other coastal towns may have different rules. Bend has two types of permits, (Type I & II) but Deschutes county outside of the city limits is fairly easy to get up and running.
• Zoning and Usage Limitations: Many municipalities have specific zoning laws that dictate where STRs are permitted. Some areas may restrict STRs to commercial zones, while others may allow them in residential areas with specific conditions (e.g., limits on the number of guests or nights rented). The coast has some exceptions for properties in commercial zones, allowing operators to skip the lengthy wait for applications.
• Occupancy and Nuisance Rules: Beyond permits, be aware of rules regarding maximum occupancy, parking, noise, and trash. Neighbor complaints can quickly lead to fines or even revocation of your operating license. Cities like Portland have non-emergency hotlines for STR complaints and may audit booking records.
• Taxes: Beyond state lodging taxes, many Oregon cities and counties levy their own transient lodging taxes. Ensure you understand all applicable taxes and how to remit them, as failure to do so can result in penalties. For example, Deschutes County has an 8% transient tax that is passed onto guests but may need to be reflected in a lower nightly rate to remain competitive.
• Evolving Regulations: The regulatory environment for STRs is dynamic. What is allowed today might change tomorrow due to community pressure or new legislation. Stay informed about proposed changes in your target areas.
• 
  

Our Recommendation: Before making any commitments, thoroughly research the specific STR regulations for the exact city and county where you intend to purchase. Contact the local planning or community development department to confirm current requirements and any pending changes. This due diligence can save you from significant legal and financial headaches down the line.

3. Understanding Financing: Second Home vs. DSCR Financing

The type of financing you secure can profoundly impact the profitability and viability of your short-term rental investment. For STRs, you'll generally encounter two primary categories: second home financing and DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) financing.

• Second Home Financing: This type of loan is for a property that is not your primary residence but is intended for your personal use for a portion of the year, in addition to being rented out. The IRS has specific guidelines for what qualifies as a second home (e.g., used for personal purposes for more than 14 days a year or 10% of the days it's rented).
• Pros: Generally offers lower interest rates and lower down payment requirements (often starting around 10%) compared to pure investment property loans. The qualification process is similar to a primary residence mortgage, focusing on your personal income and debt-to-income (DTI) ratio.
• Cons: Comes with limitations on personal use and rental days (e.g., cannot be rented out for more than 180 days a year by some lenders). If you primarily intend to use the property as a full-time rental income generator, it may not qualify, or you could face issues if you exceed personal use limits.
• DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) Financing: Specifically designed for investment properties and assess the property's ability to generate enough income to cover its debt obligations. The key metric is the DSCR ratio, which compares the property's net operating income to its debt service (mortgage payments). A DSCR of 1.0 means the income just covers the debt; lenders typically prefer ratios of 1.25 or higher.
• Pros: Does not rely on your personal income or DTI for qualification, making them ideal for investors with multiple properties or non-traditional income streams. Lenders evaluate the property's projected rental income. Crucially, many DSCR lenders will consider projected short-term rental income based on market data (e.g., AirDNA reports) rather than requiring a long-term tenant history. They often have no limit on the number of financed properties.
• Cons: Typically come with higher interest rates and higher down payment requirements (often 20-30% or more) compared to second home loans. The focus is purely on the property's income potential, so if a property isn't projected to cash flow well, it may not qualify. These are generally non-qualified mortgages (non-QM) and can be less regulated. To acquire a DSCR loan most lenders will require the property has 2 years of profitable operating history.

Our Recommendation: For investors whose primary goal is yield and who plan minimal personal use, DSCR financing for an existing or strong projected STR is often the more suitable and scalable option, despite the higher rates. If you genuinely intend to use the property regularly as a vacation home with some rental income to offset costs, second home financing might be more appropriate. Always work with a lender experienced in investment properties and STRs to ensure you choose the right product for your specific goals.

4. Management: Important and Expensive, or Energy Intensive for Owner-Managers

Effective property management is the backbone of a successful short-term rental, yet it comes with significant considerations.

• Professional Management (Expensive): Hiring a professional short-term rental management company can be a game-changer, especially for out-of-state investors or those with limited time. These companies handle everything from marketing, booking, guest communication, cleaning coordination, maintenance, and even dynamic pricing strategies.
• Cost: Expect professional management fees to range anywhere from 20% to 30% of the effective gross income. This percentage can vary based on the level of service, the property's location (e.g., highly seasonal areas might charge more), and the amenities offered. While 25-30% is a common high-end figure, some companies like Evolve may offer services starting as low as 10% for more limited offerings. Be sure to understand what services are included (e.g., is cleaning separate?).
• Benefits: Frees up your time, leverages their expertise in pricing and marketing, ensures consistent guest experiences, and can handle emergencies.
• Owner-Managed (Energy Intensive): Many investors initially consider managing their own STRs to save on fees. While this can save money, it is incredibly energy intensive.
• Responsibilities: This includes 24/7 guest communication, managing booking calendars across multiple platforms, coordinating cleaning and maintenance, handling emergencies (often at odd hours), addressing guest complaints, ensuring compliance with local regulations, restocking supplies, and actively marketing your property.
• Time Commitment: This is essentially running a small hospitality business. The time commitment can be substantial, especially during peak seasons or if you have multiple properties. Burnout is a real risk.
• Opportunity Cost: The time spent managing could be time spent on other income-generating activities or simply enjoying your life.
• 
  

Our Recommendation: Factor management costs into your financial projections from the outset. For most serious investors seeking yield, professional management is often a necessary expense to ensure optimal performance and protect your peace of mind. For those considering owner-management, be realistic about the significant time and effort required.

5. Deciding Your Purpose: Personal Use vs. Investment Yield

Before diving into the STR market, clarify your primary objective for owning the asset:

• Personal Use (A Property That Pays for Most of Itself): Your primary goal is to own a vacation home or a retreat in a desirable Oregon location (e.g., the coast, Bend, Wine country) that you and your family can enjoy regularly. The rental income is a secondary benefit, aimed at offsetting mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs.
• Considerations: Your personal preferences for location, amenities, and aesthetic will heavily influence your purchase decision. You'll likely prioritize proximity to your favorite activities or natural attractions. Tax implications also differ for second homes (see financing section). The property will likely have periods of personal use, reducing its income-generating potential.
• Investment (Seeking Yield): Your sole or primary objective is to generate significant passive income and achieve a strong return on investment (ROI). Personal use is minimal or non-existent, and every decision is driven by maximizing rental revenue and profitability.
• Considerations: Location selection will be driven by market demand, average daily rates, and occupancy projections, not personal preference. Property amenities will be chosen based on what attracts the most guests and commands the highest rates. You'll focus heavily on financial metrics like cash flow, principal reduction and potential appreciation. DSCR financing is often more suitable here.
• 
  

Our Recommendation: Be honest with yourself about your true motivation. A property purchased primarily for personal enjoyment may not always be the most financially optimized investment, and vice-versa. Understanding your goal will guide your property selection, financing strategy, and management approach. Constant Commercial Real Estate Inc can quantify the return projections with real analysis from actual short term rentals for sale over the years. Our stance comes from underwriting 100's of them and owning them ourselves. We see the social media experts and owners in other markets touting high income and specialized properties - we are not here to state its not possible, but the vast majority of them struggle with high yield due to the above factors.

Conclusion

The short-term rental market in Oregon, while still offering opportunities, is maturing and demanding a more sophisticated approach from investors. The days of easily achieving outsized returns are likely behind us, replaced by a need for diligent research, realistic financial projections, and strategic execution. By embracing moderate leverage, meticulously understanding local regulations, selecting the right financing, budgeting for professional management (or committing to the intensive work of self-management), and clearly defining your investment goals, you can still find success in the evolving Oregon short-term rental landscape. As always, consulting with experienced real estate professionals and financial advisors is paramount to making informed decisions that align with your individual investment objectives.

.